« St Louis Blues | Main | Prove It On Me Blues »
Thursday
15Oct2009

Ma Rainey's Wringing and Twisting Blues

In the song Wringing and Twisting Blues by Ma Rainey her despair and violence is laced throughout the lyrics, melody, and accompaniment. Another woman stole her man away and her grief turns to anger and a lust for revenge. The sorrowful pitch and slow rhythm reflect the hurt that she has experienced. The shape of the song builds on her wanting to get even. The lyrics portray these strong emotions,

“But if I know that woman that caused my heart to moan

I’d cook a special dinner, invite her to my home

…………………………………………….………

If she eats on my table, she will be graveyard bound

I’ll be right there to tell her, when they put her in the ground

You’re the cause of me having those wringin’ and a-twistin’ blues.’”

 

The melody has a distinct blue note that sums up her loss. The accompaniment has a wonderful texture with the chords and notes that in all produce a longing rhythm. This song demonstrates the relationship between men and women, but especially women and women. Her love had another woman on the side and her first reaction is not to blame her man, it is to get revenge on the woman who stole him away. It exemplifies the violence and competition between women.  The relationship between the man and woman is that he is not responsible the other woman is, allowing him to get off easy because it is only the women’s fault. This song demonstrates perfectly the anguish and hatred that this woman experienced. Ma Rainey exemplifies all the defining characteristics of the blues through this song.

 

 

Melissa Stoll

 

 

 

               

Reader Comments (1)

Those of you that wrote about “Prove It On Me,” you all felt that the song was definitely an expression of an empowered woman. Some of you even feel that she is so empowered as to feel comfortable expressing her homosexual feelings, by dressing and acting like a man. Do you feel this song expresses an empowered lesbian or just an empowered straight woman? Or is that even an important distinction here? I liked the comparison that the following posts made with modern portrayals in pop music of lesbian relationships which are less about the women and more about men liking the idea of two girls together. What do you think? Is modern pop culture limited in the way it expresses female/female love? Do you think this song was controversial when it was released? Please respond to one of the two posts below to add your thoughts to the discussion.
http://benleedscarson.com/ma-rainey-and-bessie-smith/girls-kissing-girls-oh-my.html
http://benleedscarson.com/ma-rainey-and-bessie-smith/prove-it-on-me-blues-1.html

Oct 16, 2009 at 2:26 PM | Registered CommenterBethRatay
Member Account Required
You must have a member account on this website in order to post comments. Log in to your account to enable posting.